Reuters interviews reveal how the removal of names from voter lists has become entangled with a wider campaign to identify and deport suspected illegal immigrants, leaving some Indian families facing detention and expulsion despite decades of records documenting their roots in the country.
When Sahida Fakir left her home in Mumbai on July 19 to buy vegetables, she told her younger son she would return within minutes. More than three months later, the 38-year-old was living in a village in Bangladesh, separated from her husband and two sons.
Fakir told Reuters that plainclothes officers detained her, seized her phone—which contained copies of her identity documents—and eventually forced her across the border. Court filings indicate that the officers belonged to the Mumbai police crime branch.
“Someone grabbed my hand from behind and ordered me to get into the vehicle,” she recalled.
Fakir is among members of 10 families interviewed by Reuters whose relatives were detained, deported or questioned over their citizenship after their names disappeared from India’s revised electoral rolls. All had Indian identity or family documents, while their parents, siblings and other relatives remained registered as voters.
The cases highlight how India’s extensive voter-list revision has become intertwined with a separate government campaign to identify and expel suspected illegal immigrants. Yet removal from electoral rolls does not, in itself, establish that an individual is a foreign national.
Muslims disproportionately affected
The nationwide revision removed 130 million names, marking the largest deletion of voters in India’s history. Data indicate that Muslims, the country’s largest religious minority, have been disproportionately affected.
Rights groups have repeatedly raised concerns about exclusionary policies and increasing discrimination against Muslims since Prime Minister Narendra Modi’s Hindu nationalist Bharatiya Janata Party (BJP) came to power in 2014.
In West Bengal, where the revision was particularly extensive, approximately nine million names were removed ahead of state elections earlier this year. Muslims accounted for around 70% of the 2.7 million names deleted following closer scrutiny, despite representing only 27% of the state’s population, according to the Kolkata-based Sabar Institute.
The BJP won the election and took control of West Bengal for the first time.
Sabir Ahamed, the institute’s founder, said voter deletions had played a significant role in determining the election outcome, alongside anti-incumbency sentiment.
The revision triggered widespread protests and accusations that the BJP was attempting to reshape the electorate in its favor. The party has denied targeting legitimate citizens.
Linking voter deletions to deportations
Home Minister Amit Shah explicitly connected the removal of names from electoral rolls with the government’s campaign against suspected illegal immigrants.
Speaking at a rally in Haryana on November 5, Shah said: “It is the BJP’s resolve that we will detect infiltrators, remove them from the electoral rolls, and after that, we will pick them out one by one and expel them from the country.”
West Bengal has become a major focal point of enforcement measures, particularly those targeting Bengali-speaking Muslims.
The issue is especially sensitive in the state because the 1947 partition of British India divided the region between India and what was then East Pakistan, which became Bangladesh in 1971. Millions crossed the newly established borders during partition and the Bangladesh independence war, leaving families and communities divided between the two countries.
Families challenge deportations in court
Fakir said she was forced into Bangladesh at around 1 a.m. through an unfenced and unguarded section of the border. Covered in mud, she walked for hours before a farmer found her crying and took her in.
Mumbai police told a court that she had been handed over to India’s Border Security Force and subsequently deported through designated authorities. Court documents indicate that Fakir was among 149 people deported during the operation after Indian authorities identified them as Bangladeshi nationals.
“I never imagined, not even for a moment, that they would send me to Bangladesh,” she said. “My home, my grandparents and my entire family lineage are rooted in India.”
Her family has challenged the deportation before the Supreme Court, arguing that removal from the electoral roll cannot determine citizenship and that she could not be expelled on the basis of an unverified administrative claim.
Documents reviewed by Reuters show that Fakir’s parents and grandparents were registered voters in West Bengal from India’s first national election in 1952. Her own name had appeared on the state’s electoral rolls since at least 2008.
However, Mumbai’s Foreigners Regional Registration Office told the Calcutta High Court that Fakir had presented a Bangladeshi birth certificate during an inquiry and failed to provide credible evidence of Indian citizenship.
Fakir rejected the allegation, saying officials had confiscated her phone and denied her the opportunity to present the documents stored on it.
Detentions and growing uncertainty
Other families have reported similar experiences. Nasiruddin Sheikh, a utensil seller, told the Calcutta High Court that he and several others were detained after their names were removed from the voter rolls, even though their appeals were still pending.
Sheikh said police detained him and 22 others while they were working in Chhattisgarh, hundreds of kilometers from their homes. Nineteen were released after 14 days when authorities found their names on the revised electoral rolls. Sheikh and three others remained in custody for 32 days.
“A policeman told me, ‘Your name is not in the voter list. You are a Bangladeshi,’” he said.
He described the detention facility as a prison where detainees were unable to leave and were subjected to medical examinations and biometric registration.
At a holding center for suspected foreign migrants in Murshidabad, Reuters reporters observed people looking out from windows, clothes hanging inside and an ambulance and covered police bus within the heavily guarded compound.
Human rights activist Kirity Roy said millions of cases challenging voter-list deletions were awaiting consideration, while special tribunals were moving too slowly to provide timely justice.
“There are millions of cases against deletion of names from voter list and people are waiting for justice,” Roy said. “The tribunals are slow. We are hopeless with what is going on.”
The growing number of cases raises questions about the relationship between electoral eligibility, citizenship verification and immigration enforcement in India, particularly for Muslim communities whose families have lived in the country for generations.
Source: Reuters

