Bahrain’s ‘Day of Nakba’: How the Crackdown on Shia Clerics Deepened

Date:

Analysts warn that the sweeping convictions could further deepen the kingdom’s political and social crisis.
The life sentences handed down to Ayatollah Sheikh Isa Qassim, Bahrain’s most prominent Shia religious authority and spiritual leader, along with dozens of other religious scholars, have triggered a fresh wave of outrage against the Al Khalifa government. Bahraini opposition groups have described the verdicts as one of the darkest days in the country’s contemporary history, calling it Bahrain’s “Day of Nakba.”
On Monday, November 16, 2026, Bahrain’s High Criminal Court convicted all 69 defendants in a mass trial. According to the Bahrain Institute for Rights and Democracy (BIRD), 64 defendants were sentenced to life imprisonment, while the remaining five received 15-year prison terms.
The defendants included 60 Shia clerics and nine individuals associated with religious activities. Of the total, 56 were already in custody, while 13 clerics were tried in absentia. Sheikh Isa Qassim, who has been living in Iran since 2018, was also sentenced to life imprisonment.
Bahraini authorities accused the defendants of establishing a group linked to Iran’s Islamic Revolutionary Guard Corps (IRGC), seeking to overthrow the political system, financing terrorism and promoting the ideology of Velayat-e Faqih (Guardianship of the Islamic Jurist).
The prosecution alleged that some defendants had used mosques, religious sermons, charitable institutions and educational activities to advance the group’s objectives.
The Bahraini government maintains that the convictions were based on criminal activities and that the defendants were afforded their legal rights. However, human rights organizations and opposition groups have strongly challenged both the charges and the judicial proceedings.
One of the most significant aspects of the case is the scale of the sentences and the fact that a substantial part of Bahrain’s Shia religious establishment has been targeted.
According to BIRD, only one of the 56 detained defendants faced an espionage charge. Meanwhile, activities such as religious teaching, maintaining contact with religious authorities abroad, receiving religious funds and engaging in charitable work were also included among the prosecution’s allegations.
Critics argue that this demonstrates how the scope of the case extends beyond security-related accusations to encompass ordinary religious activities.

Protests in Bahrain and International Condemnation
The verdicts have sparked protests in several parts of Bahrain. Images and reports from predominantly Shia areas, including a demonstration in the village of Malikiyah on November 15, show protesters carrying photographs of religious scholars and denouncing the arrests and severe sentences.
Al-Wefaq National Islamic Society, Bahrain’s largest opposition organization, described the verdicts as collective punishment targeting the country’s Shia majority.
International criticism had also emerged before the verdicts were announced. Several leading human rights organizations had raised concerns about the trial and warned of serious violations of the defendants’ rights.
In a joint statement issued on November 10, 20 human rights organizations, including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, Americans for Democracy and Human Rights in Bahrain, the International Federation for Human Rights (FIDH) and the World Organisation Against Torture (OMCT), expressed serious concerns over the proceedings.
The organizations reported allegations of torture, ill-treatment, coerced confessions, detention without access to legal counsel and closed-door hearings.
According to the statement, some defendants were allegedly subjected to sleep deprivation, prolonged periods of blindfolding and handcuffing, threats of physical and sexual violence against themselves and their families, and threats of revocation of their citizenship.
The organizations called for independent investigations into the torture allegations, the exclusion of confessions obtained under duress, guarantees of fair trials and the release of individuals detained for peaceful religious activities.
Human Rights Watch warned that the mass prosecution of clerics raised serious concerns about the targeting of religious life and the social leadership of Bahrain’s Shia community.
The organization emphasized that imprisoning imams and religious scholars responsible for leading large congregations goes beyond the detention of individual figures. Such measures can disrupt religious life, religious education and collective rituals within an entire community.
Following the announcement of the verdicts, BIRD also condemned the ruling.
Sayed Ahmed Alwadaei, the institute’s director of advocacy, said the defendants had become victims of regional developments. He argued that their prosecution had separated religious leaders from their communities and exposed their families to fear and insecurity.
The institute called for an independent investigation into allegations of torture and the overturning of convictions based on coerced confessions or unfair proceedings.
Al-Wefaq also described the sentences as collective punishment against Bahrain’s Shia majority and part of what it called a systematic government policy aimed at suppressing the community’s religious and political symbols.
The organization warned that targeting prominent religious figures would further undermine the prospects for national reconciliation and a political settlement in Bahrain.

Sheikh Isa Qassim: From Citizenship Revocation to Life Imprisonment
Among those sentenced, Sheikh Isa Qassim holds particular significance.
One of Bahrain’s most prominent Shia scholars and a spiritual leader of the opposition movement, Qassim has played a central role in the political and religious demands of the country’s Shia community for decades.
His importance extends beyond political activism. His religious and social influence has made him one of the most prominent authorities consulted by a substantial section of Bahraini society.
The first major confrontation between the government and Sheikh Isa Qassim took place in 2016, when Bahrain’s Interior Ministry revoked his citizenship on June 20.
Bahraini officials accused him of harming national interests by supporting foreign religious and political leaders and fostering sectarian divisions. The decision, however, triggered widespread public anger and led to a prolonged sit-in outside his residence in the village of Diraz.
The government subsequently opened a criminal case against Qassim and two of his associates, accusing them of money laundering and illegally collecting funds. Qassim and his supporters rejected the allegations, maintaining that the funds were related to religious obligations and established practices within Bahrain’s Shia community.
In May 2017, a court sentenced him to one year in prison, suspended.
On May 23, 2017, Bahraini security forces entered Diraz to disperse the sit-in outside his residence. The operation led to deadly clashes. According to Amnesty International, five protesters were killed and dozens injured, while hundreds of people were arrested.
Amnesty International strongly criticized the use of force against protesters and called for an independent investigation into the operation.
Sheikh Isa Qassim left Bahrain in 2018 and has since been living in Iran. The life sentence now imposed on him, following the revocation of his citizenship, his trial and years of restrictions on his religious and social activities, marks another stage in the government’s campaign against one of the most influential religious figures associated with the Bahraini opposition.
In response to the latest verdicts, Qassim issued a statement titled “The Day of Imprisoning the Scholars,” describing the Al Khalifa government’s policies as an attempt to turn Bahrain into a captive country and its people into a population of slaves.
He wrote: “It is impossible for our faithful nation not to resist a policy of enslavement, humiliation and marginalization, no matter how severe the hardships become. It is impossible for it to remain silent in the face of the seizure of its rights or to abandon the path of demanding them.”
He also stressed that imprisoning religious scholars would not weaken the people’s determination but would instead strengthen their resolve to continue pursuing freedom, dignity and their full rights.

Historical Roots: A Long-Standing Confrontation Between Al Khalifa and Bahrain’s Muslim Community
To understand the significance of the latest verdicts, they must be examined within the historical context of relations between the Al Khalifa ruling family and Bahrain’s Shia community.
The Al Khalifa family has ruled Bahrain since 1783. However, political demands and organized opposition to the country’s power structure, particularly in modern history, have a much longer record.
One of the earliest significant examples dates back to 1938, when activists from both the Shia and Sunni communities called for an elected legislative assembly, greater public participation in governance and political reforms.
The movement was met with the arrest and exile of several of its leaders.
In 1954, the Higher Executive Council was established with the participation of Shia and Sunni political forces. It pursued demands including an elected parliament, legal reforms and the establishment of a supreme court.
Following Bahrain’s independence in 1971, the 1973 Constitution and the establishment of the National Assembly created an opportunity for different groups to participate in the political process.
Notably, Sheikh Isa Qassim and Sheikh Abdul Amir al-Jamri, two prominent Shia clerics, served in the National Assembly. Yet the Al Khalifa government now claims that Sheikh Qassim is not Bahraini.
This political opening did not last long. In 1975, after the National Assembly rejected a proposed state security law, the then-emir dissolved parliament and suspended the Constitution.
The country was subsequently governed by decree for many years, while political freedoms were severely restricted. This period also led to the departure of several Shia religious and political figures from Bahrain.
When King Hamad bin Isa Al Khalifa came to power in 1999 and introduced the National Action Charter in 2001, hopes emerged for political reforms and a transition toward a constitutional monarchy.
Nevertheless, disagreements over the distribution of power, the authority of parliament and the extent of genuine public participation continued.
The next major turning point came with the widespread protests of 2011. Large numbers of Bahrainis gathered at Manama’s Pearl Roundabout, demanding political reforms, an elected government and an end to discrimination.
The Bahraini government responded by declaring a state of emergency and suppressing the demonstrations, with military assistance, particularly from Saudi Arabia through the Peninsula Shield Force.
The Bahrain Independent Commission of Inquiry, established by order of the king, documented numerous cases of disproportionate use of force, torture and ill-treatment of detainees.
Reports by the US State Department also documented widespread targeting of the Shia community during the crackdown. Large numbers of Shia employees were dismissed or suspended, while several Shia mosques and religious centers were demolished.
The commission also identified what it described as a “culture of impunity” within the security forces.
In subsequent years, pressure on political and religious movements continued. The dissolution of Al-Wefaq, the kingdom’s largest opposition political organization, in 2016, the arrest and prosecution of political activists, restrictions on clerics and the revocation of citizenship from government critics further narrowed Bahrain’s political space.
In its 2017 report, Human Rights Watch described the simultaneous crackdown on Al-Wefaq, human rights activists and Shia clerics as evidence of a deteriorating environment for freedom of expression, assembly and association.
The organization also warned that such measures were undermining the prospects for a political solution to Bahrain’s domestic crisis.
From this perspective, the latest case cannot be viewed as an isolated judicial development. Rather, it is part of a broader pattern of government actions that have affected the social and religious structure of Bahrain’s Shia community, ranging from restrictions on political organizations to citizenship revocations and the imprisonment of religious scholars.

 

Why Are Islamic Clerics Being Targeted?
One of the central questions surrounding the latest verdicts is why religious scholars have become the principal targets of this case.
Taher al-Mousawi, a prominent figure in Bahrain’s Al-Wefaq opposition society, argues that the arrest and prosecution of clerics should be understood beyond the framework of a judicial dispute, within the broader context of Bahrain’s political and social crisis.
He points out that Shia clerics have historically played a role in Bahraini society that is not primarily associated with political competition or struggles for power. Instead, they have been responsible for charitable activities, religious education, social development and providing spiritual guidance to the public.
Al-Mousawi argues that the detained scholars have been among the factors contributing to social cohesion, relations between different groups and stability within society.
In his view, targeting these figures could generate a crisis extending beyond political disagreements and turn into a broader challenge to religious and social coexistence in Bahrain.
He describes Bahrain as a diverse society in religious, ethnic and political terms, where historical relations between citizens and the government were partly built on respect for religious differences and freedoms. However, he warns that targeting clerics now threatens these foundations.
Political writer and analyst Samir Ayoub also considers the latest sentences political rather than judicial in nature.
He argues that the Bahraini government has so far failed to present credible evidence linking protesters to security-related activities, maintaining that public demands have largely centered on political reforms and the restoration of citizens’ rights.
Ayoub also believes regional developments have contributed to the intensification of government pressure. In his assessment, developments involving Iran and Yemen, as well as broader regional rivalries, may have influenced the Bahraini government’s calculations.
Pointing to the presence of US military bases in Bahrain and the kingdom’s position regarding the war against Iran, he argues that foreign support for the government has created an environment in which human rights violations can be overlooked.
Political writer and researcher Hassan Alyan has also criticized the judicial proceedings, describing them as falling short of even the minimum standards of a fair trial.
He points to the size of the case file, reportedly comprising approximately 6,700 pages, and the limited time available to lawyers to examine the evidence and prepare their defense.
According to Alyan, defense lawyers were not even informed in a timely manner about the final stages of the proceedings in the days leading up to the verdict.
Political researcher Ali Zurayq, meanwhile, has emphasized Bahrain’s international legal obligations. He notes that Bahrain joined the International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights in 2006 and is therefore obligated to respect religious freedoms, the right to peaceful assembly and fair-trial standards.
In his view, the issue is not simply the number of people convicted. The nature of the charges, the independence of the judiciary and the genuine participation of the country’s majority population in the political system are equally important.

Further Escalation or the End of National Reconciliation?
The latest verdicts come as Bahrain faces heightened regional tensions and the repercussions of the war against Iran.
Reports indicate that the mass arrests of Shia clerics began in May 2026, with dozens more subsequently detained in connection with the same case.
Samir Ayoub argues that by linking domestic religious and political demands to regional developments, the Bahraini government is attempting to portray internal dissent as a security threat.
He considers this approach not a solution to the country’s crisis but rather an attempt to exact revenge and silence critics.
The Bahraini government, by contrast, insists that the case has nothing to do with religious freedoms and that the defendants were convicted because of criminal activities and links to a terrorist organization.
Officials have also maintained that the convicted individuals retain the right to appeal.
This position comes as human rights organizations continue to demand independent investigations into allegations of torture and effective guarantees of the defendants’ right to legal defense.
Ultimately, the significance of this case lies in the position occupied by the detained clerics within Bahrain’s religious and social structure.
Imprisoning dozens of religious scholars and sentencing a prominent figure such as Sheikh Isa Qassim to life imprisonment goes beyond the prosecution of a number of political opponents. It risks deepening the divide between the government and a substantial section of Bahraini society.
For this reason, the term “Bahrain’s Day of Nakba,” used by opposition figures in reference to the tragedy of the occupation of Palestine, reflects more than anger over a judicial ruling. It expresses deeper concerns about the future of religious freedoms, political participation and the possibility of coexistence in a country where the crisis of trust between the government and a large part of its population remains unresolved after years of confrontation.

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Iran’s Velayati: Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani’s Scholarly Standing Was a Pillar for the Seminary

Hawzah News Agency- In his message, Velayati said the...

Grand Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani, One of Shia Islam’s Most Senior Clerics, Passes Away

Hawzah News Agency- In a statement released on Wednesday,...