Is Everything We Desire Truly Good for Us?

Date:

Hawzah News Agency | In the eighteenth supplication of Al-Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya, Imam Zayn al-Abidin, peace be upon him, addresses Almighty Allah, saying:

«اَللَّهُمَّ لَکَ الْحَمْدُ عَلَی حُسْنِ قَضَائِکَ وَ بِمَا صَرَفْتَ عَنِّی مِنْ بَلاَئِکَ‏»

“O Allah, praise be to You for the good decree You have ordained for me, and for the afflictions You have warded off from me.”

«فَلاَ تَجْعَلْ حَظِّی مِنْ رَحْمَتِکَ مَا عَجَّلْتَ لِی مِنْ عَافِیَتِکَ فَأَکُونَ قَدْ شَقِیتُ بِمَا أَحْبَبْتُ وَ سَعِدَ غَیْرِی بِمَا کَرِهْتُ‏.»

“Let not the well-being You have presently bestowed upon me be the entirety of my share of Your mercy, lest that which I have loved become the cause of my misery, while another attains felicity through that which I have disliked.”

Commentary:

This supplication of Imam al-Sajjad, peace be upon him, found in Al-Sahifa al-Sajjadiyya, invites us to look beyond our limited worldly desires and toward a deeper horizon shaped by divine mercy, wisdom, and felicity. In these passages, the Imam not only teaches us how to express gratitude to Allah, but also introduces a different criterion for assessing blessings and happiness: not everything we find pleasing is necessarily in our ultimate best interest, and not everything we find displeasing is necessarily a genuine evil.

The Imam begins with praise, but not merely praise for manifest blessings; rather, he praises Allah for the goodness of His decree (husn al-qadha’). The term qadha’ refers to divine decree and judgment, while husn emphasizes its goodness and wisdom. The Imam does not say, “O Allah, I praise You because You have always acted according to my wishes.” Rather, he says, “I praise You because what You ordain for me is grounded in Your knowledge and wisdom.”

The distinction between these two perspectives is profound. Ordinarily, we feel grateful when life unfolds according to our wishes: when we enjoy good health, our affairs are in order, our loved ones are by our side, and our future develops according to our plans. Yet deeper faith is manifested when, alongside enjoying blessings, we are able not to turn away from Allah even when we do not yet understand the wisdom behind what has befallen us.

After praising Allah for His decree and for the afflictions He has averted, the Imam offers an even deeper supplication: O Allah, let not my share of Your mercy be limited to the well-being and comfort You have granted me in this world.

The term ‘afiyah (well-being) carries a broad meaning here, encompassing health, security, comfort, and freedom from worldly hardships. The expression ma ajjalta li (“that which You have hastened for me”) also refers to what has been bestowed upon a person in this worldly life.

The Imam, peace be upon him, does not reject well-being; it is a valuable blessing that one should seek from Allah and be grateful for. Rather, his concern is that a person might reduce divine mercy to worldly comfort alone and become heedless of the more expansive mercy of Allah, which encompasses spiritual growth and eternal felicity.

Imagine someone who is spared illness, poverty, and major difficulties, yet this very comfort leads them to heedlessness, arrogance, indifference toward the needy, and forgetfulness of Allah. By contrast, another person may encounter hardships along the way, but those very difficulties may bring them closer to patience, empathy, reliance upon Allah, reflection on their conduct, and a return to Him.

Can we, then, judge the ultimate happiness of these two individuals solely on the basis of their outwardly comfortable circumstances?

The Imam’s criterion is not merely today’s ease, but the ultimate outcome of one’s life and the quality of one’s relationship with Allah. Well-being becomes a more complete blessing when it does not lead to heedlessness, and hardship may become an opportunity for growth when accompanied by patience, awareness, and righteous action.

Of course, this should not lead us to conclude that every person afflicted with hardship is necessarily closer to Allah, or that everyone who enjoys worldly blessings is spiritually distant from divine mercy. Suffering, in and of itself, is not a sign of virtue, nor is comfort, in and of itself, a sign of spiritual deprivation. What matters is how a person responds to their circumstances and the effect those circumstances have on their faith, character, and conduct.

The Imam, peace be upon him, asks Allah that what he has loved and rejoiced in attaining in this world not ultimately become the cause of his misery, while another person attains felicity through something he himself has disliked. Thus, there is not always a correspondence between what a person desires and what is truly beneficial for them.

We often make decisions based on limited information, fleeting emotions, and our immediate needs. We love something because it brings us pleasure, and we dislike something because it does not suit our comfort. Yet true felicity may sometimes depend on criteria that transcend fleeting pleasure and pain. This is why the concluding statement of the Imam at the end of this very supplication is also particularly thought-provoking:

«فَغَیْرُ کَثِیرٍ مَا عَاقِبَتُهُ الْفَنَاءُ وَ غَیْرُ قَلِیلٍ مَا عَاقِبَتُهُ الْبَقَاءُ.»

“That which leads to perishing is insignificant, however abundant it may be, and that which leads to lastingness is abundant, however little it may be.”

———————————————————————————–

The International Service of “Hawzah News Agency”

Kaynak: Hawzah

LEAVE A REPLY

Please enter your comment!
Please enter your name here

Share post:

Subscribe

Popular

More like this
Related

Seminary Official: Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani’s Scholarly Legacy Will Remain a Guiding Light for Researchers

Hawzah News Agency- In his message, Seifi Amoli described...

Ayatollah Saeedi: Islamic Countries That Give Bases to America Are Worse Than Infidels

Hawzah News Agency- Speaking at Friday prayers at the...

Iran’s Islamic Revolution is the only force blocking West’s final bid for global domination: senior cleric

Hawzah News Agency- Hojatoleslam Seyyed Mahdi Mirbaqeri made the...

Grand Ayatollah Vahid Khorasani, One of Shia Islam’s Most Senior Clerics, Passes Away

Hawzah News Agency- In a statement released on Wednesday,...